Atheists: Don’t You Ever Get Depressed?
I used to believe in God and am now an atheist of sorts. However, unlike some people who seem to have rejoiced in the liberation from religious shackles it represents, I find I cannot embrace this worldview happily. I struggle with motivation and have struggled with depression for a long time due to many factors and difficult life experiences. I find life quite empty now without the belief in a deeper structure and meaning to the Cosmos. While I find religious beliefs absurd, atheism is certainly not something I’d want to proclaim to anyone and I really do genuinely want there to be a Higher Reality out there. As an ex-theist, accepting that life is just a case of “enjoy yourself while you’re here and be happy, treat people well, make your own meaning, etc., etc.”, while admirable, still seems totally inadequate. People will probably accuse me of being weak, or ungrateful for the gift of life or whatever. But for me it is inadequate because I care about a lot of issues and find it very hard to accept an unjust universe with no inherent purpose or care what happens to us or how we act. Perhaps it is simply unmet emotional needs on my part due to my lacking a strong father figure in my own life and a sense of social belonging. But I do find it patronising when people make light of the human condition, that to have a problem with life implies a weak character, when many of the great figures and writers in history (Albert Camus? Bertrand Russell?) have wrestled with this existential despair at life’s futility and the harshness of nature. Life for me has not generally been a happy experience and I find this sort of philosophy shallow and unfulfilling. Except it seems a lot of atheists are genuinely satisfied in their position and take pride in it (although arguably some of this is driven by an anti-religious zeal which seems to give some people a sort of purpose). Are there any other people like me out there? I wonder if it is because of my previous spiritual background, which is why I feel the loss of God in my life so much more keenly than, say, someone who grew up as an atheist. They never experienced this shattering of their worldview nor had to accept the blow to their pride in admitting that everything they believed was false. This is perhaps why I find it difficult to relate to the “atheist community” in general (obviously there is no such thing but I hope you get what I mean). So are there any of you atheists out there who have had mental health problems and know what I’m talking about, who maybe secretly would prefer it if there was a “God” of some kind, and who are honest enough to admit it? Also how do you deal with it?
Please try and be respectful in your answers. Thanks.
P.S. I don’t mean “God” in a childish anthropomorphic popular conception, the sort of stereotypical God some famous atheists use to discredit religion. But something much more subtle. Higher Reality/ Intelligence or whatever you want to call it, since presumably “God”, if such an entity exists, would be beyond our comprehension anyway.














